no comments

Manchester apartment dwellers recycle far less than house residents, costing the Earth and the city a fortune

Stories on the threat of climate change, environmental protests against pollution and the government’s often hollow promises to address the issue seem to hit the news every day. Many will be relieved by Manchester City Council’s declaration last Wednesday of a climate emergency, to address the issues faster in the region.

In a city that is seeing a huge amount of high-rise residential blocks being built, data released by the council shows that the residents of these blocks are lagging far behind house dwellers in the amount of rubbish they recycle. Costing the earth in the deleterious effects of this waste on climate change and pollution of the environment, and by the council spending considerably more due to the greater expense of disposing unrecycled waste.

Statistics revealed by the councils, Neighbourhoods and Environmental Scrutiny Committee, show that managers of these blocks and the apartment dwellers have been lagging behind in their efforts to help reduce the amount of unrecycled rubbish they send to landfill sites and incinerators.

How big a problem is this?

People that live in houses in Manchester have a recycling rate of 50% of their total household waste, while apartment dwellers are only contributing 10% to the recycle bins.

This is a problem for the environment and the public purse. The cost of collecting general waste is £357 per tonne (p/t). It only costs £30 p/t for materials in the blue and brown bins and £55 p/t to recycle organic waste in the green bin. Currently Manchester has the lowest recycling rate across the ten boroughs of Greater Manchester, which means it also has the highest disposal costs. The estimated cost of waste and recycling in Manchester for 2019/20 is £63.6 million, which is 10.4% of the council tax budget. The council hopes to save half a million pounds from 2018 to 2020 by engaging the city’s apartment sector in recycling.

Meteor graphic: Waste disposal costs, by type, in Manchester in 2019. Blue bin contents: paper, cardboard, magazines, etc. Brown bin: glass bottles, plastic bottles, tin cans, foil containers, etc. Green bin: all food waste and garden waste such as grass and hedge cuttings. Source: Manchester City Council

Using the figures for the cost of waste disposal and the amount of waste recycled provided by Manchester City Council The Meteor has estimated the costs and weight of general waste disposed per person per year in Manchester; using an average weight of 403 kg of household waste per person per year across England in 2017. The estimated annual extra cost to the council for disposing general waste per resident of an apartment block, compared to the costs of a house resident, is £74.70.

recycle

Meteor graphic: Estimated cost, and weight of general waste disposed per person per year in Manchester, differentiated by dwelling type. The average total household waste disposed per person in England in 2017 is 403 kg. The values for percentage of waste recycled (10% for apartments and 50% for houses) and the cost of general waste disposal (£357 p/t) provided by MCC were then used to calculate the figures presented.

With a current city centre population of 50,000 and a projection of 80,000 by 2024, with most of the development being in the apartment sector, recycling by apartment inhabitants becomes even more significant.


WHERE DOES MANCHESTER’S RUBBISH AND WASTE GET RECYLED? CLICK HERE TO FIND OUT.

General Waste: Sent by rail to an energy recovery plant (combined heat and power plant) in Runcorn, where it is used to generate electricity and steam that is fed into the national grid.

Material in Recycled Bins: Taken to a Material Recovery Facility (MRF) in Sharston. Plastic and glass bottles/jars, foil, food/drink tins, and aerosols are separated, bulked up, and baled for reprocessing companies. Paper and card is taken to a MFR where it is sorted and graded before being taken to reprocessing companies. Reprocessing companies then recycle back into new products.

Food and Garden Waste: Delivered to In Vessel Composting facilities (IVC). The IVC system harnesses the natural composting process to recycle into compost in 6 weeks. It is then used as a soil improver on agricultural land.

Source: Jonathan Rees, Communication Officer, Manchester City Council


Factors contributing to low recycling rates by apartments

The council says some of the causes for these low recycling rates are: the lack of consequence to the resident of low recycling rates, the cost of recycling bins to apartment buildings, lack of space, cleanliness, and maintenance of bin areas, distance to and location of the bins, and a large tenant turnover making it difficult to change behaviour through education.

Composting of food waste is ignored in many apartment buildings. One possible reason behind this is fears about hygiene, as some apartment residents in Manchester reported feeling uncomfortable with the possibility of bad odours and insects.

What is being done to improve recycling?

Manchester City Centre Councillor, Jon-Connor Lyons, told The Meteor, that the council is implementing compulsory recycling  in the city centre. This will involve calculating an estimated amount for how much general waste a building should have, determined by number of residents, and then charging the building managers for any waste over that limit. He spoke of other councillors, in areas mostly made up of houses, who “were getting angry and saying that in their area the residents have to recycle but in the city centre it is not the case.”

recycle

Councillor Jon-Connor Lyons. Photo: Dale Anne McAulay

Lyons also indicated the importance of education as indicated in a recent market stall, when people were asked to place items in the correct bin. He said that people were putting things in the wrong bin and that there were many misconceptions. The council has now distributed literature to explain what should go in which bin. They are also working with building owners and managers to increase knowledge, as well as emphasising personal responsibility in regards to waste disposal.

Incentives have also been explored to increase recycling, such as deposit returning bottle recycling machines at supermarkets, explained Lyon, who also wants to work with building caretakers to encourage the  use of social media, to help residents participate in recycling programmes. He also felt because of the transitory population, it was difficult to keep on top of education and so it must be ongoing.

More bins are now being distributed, at no charge, to building managers, with a potential to give residents small bins and bin bags to use inside their properties. The Neighbourhood and Environmental Team of Manchester are also speaking to building managers about positioning of bins.

Composting of food waste is ignored in many apartment buildings. This may be partly due to hygiene issues as some some apartment residents in Manchester reported feeling uncomfortable with the possibility of bad odours and insects due to the waste being kept in their apartments. Recycle for Greater Manchester are running a Bags and Caddies campaign to try and address the issue.

Food waste is a problem

According to BIFFA, Manchester’s waste disposal contractor, removal of food waste for composting is available to all apartment buildings. In response to a question about apartment recycling, BIFFA replied:

“An organic [food and garden] recycling service is available to all residents in Manchester. At apartments that do not currently offer food recycling, the building manager, caretaker, landlord or residents committee can contact the Waste, Recycling & Street Cleansing Team to request the materials required [a bin, leaflets, kitchen caddies and liners] and arrange a regular collection of the bin. This can all be done without charge.”


WHY WE MUST RECYCLE FOOD WASTE - CLICK HERE TO FIND OUT MORE

Some UK Facts!

  • Around 40% of Food Waste generated is currently disposed of via landfill.
  • The process of layering general waste creates methane. Methane has a global warming potential 21 times greater than carbon dioxide.
  • Methane from landfill represents 40% of all UK’s methane.

Source: Vision 2020


So it appears the provision is there, but to get building managers and residents to improve recycling rates it appears that further initiatives will need to be promoted

What other city centres do

Fifteen years ago, Ljubljana, capital of Slovenia, decided to commit to zero waste. They were putting all of their rubbish in landfill but by 2025 they aim for 75% to be recycled; they are using a number of initiatives to achieve this. In the city centre, where it is difficult to find space, underground containers were installed with entry cards issued to residents. Scheduled collections of general waste were halved, to force people to recycle. Door to door collections of biodegradable waste were organized. Bins were relocated making it easier to recycle, zero waste/no packaging stores, mandated toilet roll made from recycled packaging, collection of rainwater (to preserve drinking water), and reselling of used items.recycle

Jennifer Maunder, Sr Executive Property Manager of Century Plaza, an apartment building in Toronto, commented that two bins are set up behind the elevators, one for organic items and the other for other recyclable items. Items in the second bin are than sorted later by the City of Toronto. Maunder also said:

“We do also have a recycling table, where residents are welcome to leave items that they feel someone else may benefit from. This ranges from electronics to books to housewares, etc., items that we want to try and keep out of the landfill.”

She went on to say, “we do not have any type of enforced policy regarding recycling nor any means of ensuring residents comply, we merely provide them the means, encourage them through continued communication, and hope that they will partake.”

What can apartment dwellers in Manchester can do to recycle more?

After investigating this story, and speaking to the people involved in disposing waste these are some suggested ways that could help high rise flat residents increase their recycling efficiency:

  • apartment dwellers can start taking personal responsibility by sorting and placing recyclable items in the correct bin, where provided.
  • apartment building managers need to provide correct bins, placed conveniently, including food waste bins if not already provided. Residents can demand this is done.
  • stop using plastic bags when shopping and lobby for zero waste packaging.
  • recycle clothing and other items by giving them to one of the many charity shops in the city centre.
  • lobby the building management to provide ongoing education and information about proper sorting, where to take old clothes and other items, as well as charity pickup services.

Just think about the benefits to the environment, the planet and the public purse that the little extra effort put into recycling waste could bring. And remember that this particular public purse is filled by council tax, so the money saved could be spent on our austerity hit police, fire and library services. Perhaps it could lead to a reduction in our council tax bill – but I wouldn’t hold your breath on that one.

 

Dale Anne McAulay

Manchester City Council recycling information on which bin to use for different types of waste

Read: Manchester declares a climate emergency: what next?

Check out our homepage for our latest stories

Featured image: The Meteor

Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.